Blog

The Most Sold-To Generation in History

A recent, thought-provoking piece by Mark Phillips caught the attention of our Director, Richard Morrow, who recently shared his perspective in his article, The Most Sold-To Generation in History. Mark explored the noticeable decline in charitable giving among younger generations, attributing it in part to cultural shifts and the concept of “doom spending”. While we at Central Mailing Services agree with much of his analysis regarding modern giving habits and the fundamental importance of making the ask, one particular idea gave us pause: is it really just “doom spending”?

To understand where we are today, it helps to look back forty years.

If you grew up in the 1980s, shopping was far from a constant, ambient activity. It was a planned event. Shops closed early, high streets had strict operating hours, and there were no sprawling out-of-town retail parks, no internet, no Amazon, no Temu and certainly no TikTok Shop attempting to monetise every spare second on your phone.

Back then, acquiring something required real physical effort. You hopped on a bike or caught a bus into town. If the shop was out of stock, that was the end of the line, you either waited until the following week or decided you didn’t really need it after all. Even traditional mail order carried significant friction: you filled out a printed order form, wrote a cheque, bought a stamp, walked to the postbox and waited weeks hoping the parcel would arrive. Every single transaction had natural hurdles to overcome.

The Gradual Erasure of Friction

Throughout the late 1980s and 1990s, the retail landscape underwent a structural transformation. Out-of-town shopping centres emerged, Sunday trading became legalised and supermarkets evolved into complete lifestyle destinations. Credit cards became ubiquitous, and soon after, the web arrived. Decade by decade, another barrier to buying was dismantled.

Then came the data revolution. Loyalty initiatives like the Tesco Clubcard weren’t merely reward schemes; they marked the moment retailers began truly capturing customer behaviour. Businesses shifted from simply selling products to building deep customer intelligence datasets.

Search engines redefined how consumers discovered brands. E-commerce platforms removed virtually every obstacle between impulse and purchase. Search engine optimisation (SEO) emerged to capture explicit search intent, while merchants gathered sophisticated insights into browsing and purchasing habits. Every innovation made buying easier for the consumer and selling smarter for the retailer.

Social media platforms transformed brand reach, short-form video made shopping a form of entertainment and artificial intelligence is now taking this capability to unprecedented heights. Modern retailers don’t just know what a customer bought; they know what was left in a cart, how long a user lingered on a product photo, which colour variation was preferred and precisely which incentive will trigger a conversion next time.

It raises a critical question: Has there ever been a generation so relentlessly sold to?

We don’t believe there has.

Today’s young adults don’t simply encounter marketing, they live inside an omnipresent commercial ecosystem. Every swipe, search, stream and click continuously trains predictive algorithms. Rather than labelling this behaviour “doom spending”, perhaps we are simply witnessing consumers responding predictably to the most sophisticated sales apparatus in human history.

What This Means for Direct Marketing

This shift isn’t just relevant to charity fundraising, it directly impacts the entire direct marketing sector.

Every campaign we deliver at CMS today operates in an environment of unprecedented noise. We are no longer competing solely against another charity appeal or rival retail catalogue in the letterbox. We are competing against smartphone notifications, influencer recommendations, hyper-targeted digital ads, personalised shopping feeds and embedded affiliate links. Furthermore, younger consumers actively seek out peer reviews, unboxing videos and social proof before making a decision, amplifying marketing messages across their own digital networks.

The battle for consumer attention has never been more intense. That is precisely why we must be cautious about faulting younger demographics for spending differently. They aren’t inherently different; they are simply navigating a marketplace built to sell with frictionless efficiency. As marketers, our job is to understand these dynamics, not criticise them.

The Enduring Strengths of Direct Mail

This modern reality is also why physical direct mail remains such a vital component of the channel mix. Direct mail does not pop up in the middle of a social media feed, nor is it forced to compete for attention between fast-scrolling videos. It lands directly in the recipient’s hands, in their home, within a quiet and tactile environment that digital channels cannot replicate.

However, channel advantage alone isn’t enough. As an industry, we cannot afford complacency. To cut through today’s noise, campaigns require stronger creative, compelling copywriting, sharper audience segmentation, higher quality data and rigorous performance measurement. Every element matters more than ever.

Ultimately, the core question isn’t whether consumer mindsets have fundamentally changed. The bigger question is whether we have built the most powerful selling machine the world has ever known, and if so, the biggest change over the past forty years hasn’t been the audience at all, but the marketplace itself.